The developer of Legendary Halo 3 explains what’s wrong with modern FPS games

If you’ve been playing Call of duty modern warfare 3, or basically any competitive multiplayer FPS game over the past few years, you’ve probably found yourself frustrated with the level of your online opponents. While CoD, Counter-Strike, and a wide variety of other shooters use the Skill-Based Matchmaking (SBMM) system, which is designed to pair you with players of similar abilities and experience, in some cases, it can make games feel too close and contested. . If you just want to play for fun and enjoyment, SBMM can be frustrating, as it results in very tight and very competitive matches. Now, with Call of Duty MW3 finally arriving, a former Bungie developer, whose credits include the multiplayer components of Halo 2 and Halo 3, discusses some of the issues with modern online shooters.

In response to an article about Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3, Max Hoberman, whose work includes not only the FPS Halo games, but older CoD games like World at War and Black Ops, discusses the design principles behind Halo 2’s legendary online multiplayer, and ” The Failure of Modern Skills-Based Matchmaking.” According to Huberman, one of the basics is contrast.

“What I implemented [in Halo] “Cleanly divide the space into ordered and unordered playlists for juggling,” says Hoberman. “The opponents that were filtered were ranked based on level. This was when I wanted a competitive match. But even then, I intentionally allowed for variation in the range of levels at which we matched you. This variation was a topic of heated debate internally, during development, 20 years ago. Obviously, no one wants to be constantly trampled on. On the other hand, it gets boring (for most people) by constantly trampling on others. However, it is fun to have the upper hand sometimes.

“By intentionally allowing a range of skills to match together, we introduced three experiences in matchmaking: an easier experience where you can kick, a harder experience where you’re potentially outmatched, and an evenly matched experience. My theory was that a good combination of those All three were perfect.

Huberman explains why modern skill-based systems may lead to less enjoyable experiences, even if they are more balanced in the strict sense. According to the former Halo developer, matching players evenly based on skill and experience may be more beneficial for viewers, but it can make the actual gameplay experience in online shooters feel “cumbersome.”

“Why don’t we always match people equally?” Huberman asks. “My thinking was that these are actually the most stressful matches of the group. Definitely, it’s the most fun for the spectators – the matches get to the end. [But] The failure of modern skill-based matchmaking, in my honest opinion, is that it is designed to maximize these perfect match scenarios and minimize others. When things are going well, the majority of games become very tight and very stressful. This is not fun for most players. Where is the contrast?

Hoberman proposes a solution, where skill-based matchmaking is combined with other types of pairing, so that players alternate between games in which they face a serious challenge, where they dominate opponents, and where there is tense, close competition. Huberman also emphasizes the importance of non-ranked matches, and how they can be subject to different rules of matchmaking ethics.

“The system I designed for categorized playlists is a healthy mix,” says Hoberman. “Sure, it’s annoying to watch your favorite team get kicked. But it comes full circle when they’re the ones kicking ass. Participate in close, identical games every now and then, and it’s a lot of fun.

“I can’t even access unranked playlists yet. I designed it to not take skill/level into account in searching for opponents. Yes, our engineers used the same code base and kept skill/level as the search criterion, but we deprioritized it significantly In matchmaking. We also didn’t track skill/level globally, just per playlist. The end result was that rankless matchmaking allowed a very wide range of skill levels to match together for what everyone agreed was casual, unimportant fun. Again “This is the way things should be, in my opinion.”

When Call of Duty, Counter-Strike, or other FPS games that use SBMM frustrate you, you may feel the solution is to separate high-ranking, high-performing players into their own lobbies. If these are the experts, who can use movement tricks, slide cancellations, and all those higher-level strategies to slaughter casual opponents, it might make sense to say that they should only play against each other. Hoberman argues that this is the “easy way out,” and that developers should try different solutions.

“Because the normal distribution of skill level of players follows a bell curve,” Huberman said He explains“There are outliers: inherent low-skilled players and high-skilled players. Describing high-skilled people as ‘sweaty teenagers jumping on Monster Energy’ is truly disrespectful. Separating high-skilled players from the general population, forcing them to Long waits are a form of discrimination.

“Designers should strive to find a way for players of all skill levels to have a good time together. Casual, no-nonsense, unranked matchmaking is one way. I’ve been as involved in handicap settings and asymmetric game mode design as others. However, it shouldn’t Game developers should take the easy way out and opt for the class by default. There’s a lot that can be done. Derogatory views like these, among game developers, are offensive – and a disservice to players.

After leaving Bungie, Hoberman founded Certain Affinity, a multiplayer design studio for hire that co-developed Halo Infinite, Doom 2016, and Halo 4, among others. In our Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3 review, we break down multiplayer, Warzone and the new campaign mode, which represents a low point in CoD’s single-player history.

Take a look at some of the best multiplayer games available right now, or maybe try Modern Warfare 3 with the best MW3 loadouts, to help you own the battlefield.

Also, while you’re here, be sure to follow us Google News For daily PC gaming news, guides and reviews.