(Montreal) The sudden departure of Quebec’s director of public health last week is further evidence of a rocky road taken by the country’s chief medical officer as the tide of the Omicron variant’s wave fights into its third year.
Released at 10:35 p.m.
D.R. Horacio Arruda, who has served as director of public health since 2012, abruptly resigned Monday after 22 months of epidemics, citing criticism of the government’s handling of the latest wave.
“Recent comments about the credibility of our ideas and our scientific rigidity undoubtedly cause a certain erosion of population cohesion,” D wrote.R. Arruda in his resignation letter.
D.R. Arruda was also on the top team of provincial health workers on duty at the time of the outbreak. D.R. Arruda et al., DRe Bonnie Henry of British Columbia, dRe D. with Deena Hinshaw of AlbertaR. Robert Strong of Nova Scotia gained prominence almost overnight, delivering reassuring voices in times of crisis.
“In the beginning, when we did not know what we did not know and there was uncertainty, the Chief Medical Officer for Public Health played an incredibly helpful role because they had to be the public face of the government. Explain what’s going on, “said Patrick Faffert, a professor of public and international affairs at the University of Ottawa who studied the role of the country’s chief medical officer.
Their status has diminished in terms of the media or public opinion – part of which is inevitable, but also due to the tensions and contradictions within that character.
Patrick Fafard, Professor of Public and International Affairs at the University of Ottawa
While health care officials play an advisory role, Faffert said each province views that role differently. During a protracted epidemic, when scientific evidence changed rapidly, they had to correct differing perspectives and work with governments that did not make decisions based solely on science. Although decision-making is in the hands of politicians, they are often left to explain policies.
Most of those in office in 2020 are in place, with the exception of DR. Arruda and DR. David Williams, originally from Ontario, faced criticism before retiring last year.
In British Columbia, dRe Henry is best known for his motto, “Be cool, be quiet, be safe,” which was also used on posters, T-shirts, masks and even a shoe.Re Henry ”was designed in his memory. Ms. who was praised as the best communicator in an encouraging tone during the presentations.Me Henry faced criticism for being a strong advocate of his position against the widespread use of rapid tests.
In Alberta, dRe Hinsha was severely criticized from being worshiped. In early 2020, his face was engraved on designer clothing and prints as he became a responsive provincial government enforcing health restrictions to protect Alberts and their healthcare system.
But in the ensuing waves, Prime Minister Jason Kenny’s government has delayed implementing the new regulations and the health system is in danger of collapsing.Me Hinsha was caught in a whirlwind between Albertans who wanted more controls and those who wanted less. It culminated in the middle of the fourth wave last summer, when thousands of surgeries were canceled and the Canadian Armed Forces called for help.
M. Kenny and MMe Hinsha acknowledged that despite the delta variation drag, they helped end the health restrictions quickly in June. Jason Kenny was held accountable for the mistake, but said he would have taken action if D hadRe Hinsha had recommended him.
“Sometimes politicians don’t help because they look at the advice they receive from their public health officials,” said Daniel Beland, professor of political science at McGill University. “Ultimately, it is important to understand that the responsibility for these decisions lies with the elected authorities, not government employees.”
However, the difference is not always understood by the public. Against the backdrop of austerity measures in Quebec, Prince Edward Island, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia, military doctors saw protests outside their homes. Some have even received death threats.
“They are scientists, they are public servants, they are experts, but they are surrounded by politics,” said Mr McGill, director of Canadian research at the University. Beland said.
This is a very difficult situation when you are really stressed, when you get death threats, when you are constantly insulted. This is difficult.
Daniel Beland, director of the Canadian Institute of Research at McGill University
In Quebec, some commentators in the media dR. Arruda, who retained his role as assistant minister, was very close to the government of Prime Minister Franசois Legal. Opposition parties have stated they will not run in the by-elections.
Faffert said it would be wise to reconsider the role in all jurisdictions as part of a wider autopsy, but it is important not to lose sight of who will make the final decisions.
“The basic thing is that we have to take our governments into account […] Not for these people, ”he said. Faffert said. “We will focus on the politicians we choose to make, not the elected officials.”
For his part, dR. Strong said he heard criticism from some and thanked others.
“I do not know if the public is tired of hearing about me,” he said.R. Strange during a conference last week. “My commitment is that Nova Scotia should be here to get rid of this infection as safely as possible. ⁇
“Music geek. Coffee lover. Devoted food scholar. Web buff. Passionate internet guru.”